clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Liverpool Fans’ Opinions Mixed on Rumors of Rafa Benítez to Everton

While some understand why Rafa might choose to manage the Toffees, others believe the move would tarnish his legacy.

Fans at Anfield hold up a red banner featuring black and white images of past Liverpool managers, including Rafa Benítez.
Fans at Anfield hold up a banner of past managers, including Rafa Benítez (2020).
Photo by Robbie Jay Barratt - AMA/Getty Images

Rafa Benítez not only achieved tremendous success as Liverpool manager, but he also seemed to fundamentally “get” both the club and the city in ways that elevate him in the pantheon of Liverpool managerial greats. Because of this connection, the building rumors suggesting he might take the Everton job have, well, caused a bit of discord — and not just for Evertonians.

I should start this off by stating that my relationship to Rafa Benítez is somewhat atypical. I don’t have the warmth of feeling for Rafa that I do for the likes of Kenny Dalglish — or our current manager, for that matter — even if I respect Rafa as a man and a manager immensely.

I don’t know exactly why, but I do know that I tend to gravitate towards the warmer, stereotypical “man-manager” style of managers, and while Rafa is demonstrably an incredibly talented manager (and I’m incredibly pleased we had him instead of the likes of José Mourinho), a warm and fuzzy fella he is not.

But even if I don’t necessarily adore Rafa as I do other managers, I whole-heartedly agree with The Anfield Wrap’s Neil Atkinson’s assessment of the manager from 2018:

“Liverpool fans do have an emotional reaction to Rafa Benítez — and that’s because he’s a very good man, not just a very good football manager.”

While Rafa is perhaps not the warmest character, he is most certainly a good man — a fact perhaps best exemplified by his donation of £96,000 to the Hillsborough Family Support Group, an action he made as Inter manager, not as the boss of Liverpool. He made this donation in person, handing Margaret Aspinall the check while giving her his well wishes for the group’s push for justice.

Because of Rafa’s deep understanding and connection to the Red side of Liverpool, the reactions to his potential appointment at Everton has been...mixed.

Many believe that his record at Liverpool combined with the aforementioned donation, among other actions, mean his legacy at Liverpool will remain intact regardless of what happens.

Some see the practical side of Rafa at work in this rumored move: it would allow him to be near his family, certainly, and the job itself might appeal to him (and not just because he doesn’t half seem to thrive on chaos).

The familial location has featured in a number of takes on Twitter, to be sure:

Still others believe a move to Everton would be too much, even for a manager with a Liverpool CV like Rafa’s.

Given that Evertonians are by no means in one mind about the appointment (there are images of bedsheets around Goodison, though I haven’t walked over to check the veracity of the images myself), the rumored move is uncertain.

How do you feel about the idea of the Liverpool great becoming the first man to manage both Liverpool and Everton? Have your say in the poll below and in the comments.


Rafa managing Everton would

This poll is closed

  • 14%
    Damage, but not erase his legacy at Liverpool
    (18 votes)
  • 56%
    Make no difference, his record and activism in the city cement him as a legend no matter what
    (69 votes)
  • 17%
    Make no difference, just seems pragmatic and I don’t care much
    (22 votes)
  • 4%
    Severely diminish his legacy at Liverpool
    (6 votes)
  • 2%
    I will no longer consider him to be a legendary Liverpool manager
    (3 votes)
  • 4%
    My opinion will depend on what he accomplishes at Everton
    (5 votes)
123 votes total Vote Now

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Liverpool Offside Daily Roundup newsletter!

A daily roundup of Liverpool FC news from Liverpool Offside